When walls and ceilings are opened during a renovation, sooner or later someone asks whether to plaster them or use drywall, often called gypsum board or simply "gips". Both methods are widely used, both can give an excellent finish, and each has situations where it clearly makes more sense. Knowing the difference helps you understand your contractor's suggestions and make better decisions.
How the two methods work
Plastering is a wet process. A mortar, based on lime, cement, gypsum or a combination, is applied directly to the masonry wall in one or more coats, levelled and smoothed. It bonds with the wall and becomes part of it.
Drywall is a dry process. Gypsum boards are fixed to a metal or timber frame, or sometimes glued directly to an existing wall. The joints between the boards are taped and filled, then the whole surface is sanded and painted. Drywall is also used to build new partition walls, suspended ceilings and boxes that hide pipes and ducts.
When plaster is the better choice
Plaster is usually the natural choice on solid masonry walls of brick, stone or concrete blocks, especially where the existing plaster has to be removed anyway. Its strengths include:
- a solid, hard surface that resists knocks and holds fixings well
- good contact with the wall, without hollow spaces behind it
- suitability for old stone and brick buildings, where breathable lime plasters help walls stay dry
- durability in hallways, stairwells and other areas with heavy use
The main drawback is time. Plaster has to dry before it can be painted, and thick coats or cold, humid weather slow this down considerably. Plastering also brings a lot of moisture into the building, which needs to be ventilated away.
When drywall makes more sense
Drywall is popular in renovations because it is fast, clean and flexible. It works especially well for:
- new partition walls that should not add much weight to floors
- ceilings, including suspended ceilings with built-in lighting
- attic conversions, where boards line sloping roofs over a layer of insulation
- hiding installations, such as pipes, cables, ventilation ducts or concealed toilet cisterns
- very uneven old walls, where levelling with plaster would require thick layers
The space behind a drywall lining can hold insulation and cables, which is a practical advantage. Special boards exist for different needs, such as moisture-resistant boards for bathrooms and fire-rated boards where higher fire resistance is needed. Your contractor should use the type that fits the room.
On the other side, drywall partitions transmit more sound than solid masonry unless they are filled with insulation and built in the right way. Heavy items such as kitchen cabinets, shelves or wall-hung toilets need reinforcement or special fixings planned in advance.
What a good finish depends on
Whichever method is used, the visible result depends on careful work. For plaster, that means a properly prepared wall, the right plaster for the substrate and enough drying time. For drywall, it means a straight, well-fixed frame, correctly spaced screws and patient joint treatment.
Finishing quality also depends on the light in the room. A wall that looks perfect under soft daylight may show every ripple when a spotlight shines along it at a low angle. If you plan strong grazing light or a glossy paint, discuss the required level of finish with your contractor beforehand, because a smoother surface takes more time to achieve.
Using both in one project
In practice, most renovations combine the two. External walls of a house may be repaired with plaster, while new interior partitions, ceilings and installation shafts are built in drywall. The important thing is that each material is used where it suits the building, and that the junctions between them, such as where a drywall ceiling meets a plastered wall, are detailed to avoid cracks.
Decorative plaster and gypsum work, including cornices and ceiling details, is another option for rooms where you want a more traditional look.
Plaster and gypsum work is one of the services Construction S provides as part of renovations and new builds in Slovenia and Croatia. If you are unsure what suits your walls and ceilings, get in touch and we will advise you on the right solution.